The Winter Guest by WC Ryan


 published 2022

set January 1921





I’ve written often about novels set in the Big Houses of Ireland, and recently specifically did a post on Annabel Davis Goff’s three books which – I didn’t really lay this out in the post – cover a short century of Irish history. Fox Walk dealt with the aftermath of the Easter Rising, as does this book. (This Cold Country was set during WW2, The Dower House in the 1950s and onwards.)

The Winter Guest has a similar setting to Fox Walk – I didn’t set out to read another book about the Ascendancy, but then I will never turn one down…




Here we have a WW1 veteran heading off to Kilcolgan House in the West of Ireland after an ambush goes wrong – there’s a car with three dead bodies in it, and one of the deaths is raising serious questions. Tom Harkin, the ex-Army Captain, knows the house and the family and one of the victims - he knew them before the War, he has his connections. You might think you’ve seen all this before, but the investigation is not exactly as you might be expecting, he is no police officer, and people are taking sides in the ongoing conflict, and there are surprises for everyone.



Harkin’s enquiries are engrossing, as he tries to find out what happened, and renew some old friendships. As ever, there are questions of who you can trust and whose side people are on: there are complex layers of loyalty and betrayal. There is also a touch of the supernatural, a house full of ghosts, something Ryan writes about very well in the proper chilling melancholy way.

I thought this was a great mixture of a crime novel, a historical, and a ghost story – a real page turner.

The location – and at least one of the female characters – reminded me of Lissadell House, here, (and another blogpost here) and the sisters that WB Yeats was so fond of, Constance Markievicz and Eva Gore Booth. Down to the initials scratched onto the glass.



I had two questions about the book: did Catholics go to Trinity College Dublin at the relevant time? And how old was the housekeeper? But that’s just me being pedantic. This was a well-written delight, full of convincing detail and a giving a real – and fair – picture of a very difficult time in Ireland’s history. And one that wasn’t going to get any easier for a good few years. The time is early 1921 – in the middle of the Irish War of Independence, a process that started with the 1916 Easter Rising. This was followed by the signing of the Treaty at the end of 1921, which led to the Irish Civil War. The pictures here are very much from that era, but come from different stages. It’s not necessary to know all the details of the history, and the key moment where the enemy changed – and most English readers wouldn’t get those nuances – but it enriches the book to know them. And special kudos to Ryan (for those who read a lot about those times) for holding back on the Black and Tans, those pivotal divisive bogeymen of the time, reduced now to the name of a drink, and mentioned only twice in the book.




The top picture of the young man and the soldiers is one I have used several times before for books set in this era. It is from the National Library of Ireland, and shows ‘A prisoner under escort in July 1922’ – that’s a little later than the setting of the book.

Constance Markieviecz is one of the group in the churchyard – 3rd from left, photo from the same source.

 The next b/w  picture  shows a woman whose cottage has been destroyed by troops in a reprisal attack.

The military in the book travel round on Crossley Tenders:

He considers his options – Sackville Street is to be avoided. There are sentries outside the GPO and O’Connell Bridge is always guarded. Capel Street is a possibility, but then he hears the distinctive rattle and wheeze of a Crossley Tender from that direction and adjusts his course to avoid it….

this  picture shows exactly that vehicle, exactly in Sackville St (which is now O’Connell St ) in Dublin..

I very much enjoyed a previous historical crime novel with a touch of the supernatural by WC Ryan, House of Ghosts.

Comments

  1. It's funny, Moira, I don't usually go for ghost stories or the supernatural aspect. But there is something about those old Irish houses that just seems like a fit with ghosts or something like them. And the mystery does sound intriguing. I'm interested in the depiction of post-war life, too. I'm glad you found this a good read.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Margot. I very much like a book where it is mostly crime, with a hint of supernatural, and that is what this one is...

      Delete
  2. In 1921 roman catholics could go to TCD - as in they'd be admitted - but the Irish church would not allow "the faithful" do so except to study something they couldn't study at a properly national and catholic university. Dr. Noel Browne, the Irish Minister of Health who tried to introduce the Mother and Child Scheme against the wishes of Irish doctors and - much more damaging - Archbishop McQuaid was a "Trinity Catholic" and that made the enmity he faced greater.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the detail. Is it true that Trinity wouldn't take Catholics for a long time, then when they finally opened the doors, the Catholic church turned their noses up and forbade Catholics from going?

      Delete
    2. TCD was founded before protestantism was invented, so the ban didn't apply then. From the reformation to 1793 RCs could attend, but graduates had to make a religious affirmation that RCs couldn't make. The "test" was changed in 1793, but RCs couldn't be part of the academic establishment until 1873 when the restriction of academic posts to members of the CofI ended (equivalent restrictions only ended at the same time at Oxford and Cambridge). However, in 1871, the RC bishops forbade members of their flock going without good cause. That ban only ended in 1970.

      Delete
    3. Whoops-a-daisy!
      The phantom name transformation strikes again!

      Delete
    4. Thank you for that, very helpful and informative.
      You can't get full use of a pseudonym (eg committing crimes, creating alibis, praising yourself online) if it pops up without your knowledge...

      Delete
    5. I hope it's just a pseudonym and not an alternative personality!

      Delete
    6. I remember 20 years ago everyone was very keen on a New Yorker cartoon 'on the internet nobody knows you're a dog'. And I've just been reading the JK Rowling which sends the reader spinning off into alternate personalities and pseudonyms. But I'm betting you are safe...

      Delete
  3. I'd be mentally translating it back into the past tense. And what about the clothes?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's a losing battle against historic present. Do you think publishers insist? I will say that clothes were not a big feature of the book - but everything else I like was in place...

      Delete

Post a Comment