Reprint of the Year Award 2020

A group of crime fiction bloggers are yet again going into battle to find out which was the best vintage mystery reprinted this year.

This is now a regular feature amongst our gang of GA enthusiasts, as organized by our Queen, Kate Jackson over at Cross-Examining Crime.

She has produced an excellent post explaining the whole business, and telling you when and how you can cast your important vote.

We each have chosen a couple of titles from the many older crime books reprinted this year, and will each argue that ours are the best...

Here’s my first one:

Too Many Bones by Ruth Sawtell Wallis (re-published by Stark House Press)

published 1943

... and it’s an absolute cracker. First recommended to me (as with so many books) by Kate herself, I was super-impressed by it. Atmosphere, plot and characters were all top-notch, and the fact that this writer is unknown and forgotten is a travesty. Yes, I feel that strongly.

Kay Ellis is a young grad student who gets a job at a museum in Hinchdale, a small mid-West town in the US. She has no money and few connections, and it is hard to make her way in life. But she is obviously smart and knows her subject, and she is grabbing the chance to take this job. This remote town has a massive endowment from a rich family, and have bought in a remarkable collection of bones – Kay can make her name here.

When she gets there, she finds that a) they are expecting a man, and are not at all happy that she is a young woman and b) that her immediate boss, Dr John Gordon, is in the same situation as her – determined to keep the job at all costs, and get on in life.

The complicating factor is Mrs Zaydee Proutman– a local girl who caught the attention of rich Mr Proutman when she was a waitress. She’s now the wealthy widow, and she has complete control over the museum in every single detail. She is not a nice woman, and ready to use her power ruthlessly. She also has a fancy for young Mr Gordon – and just how far is he prepared to go to stay in her good books?

Kay and John (apparently the only two young people in town anyway) are immediately attracted to each other, but (as Kate points out in her review,) the book is very unusual in that you don’t have the faintest idea whether he is a viable prospect, a trustworthy person, a good match for Kay– or even a murderer. Tommy and Tuppence, they aren’t.

Because of course someone is murdered, and everyone is under suspicion.

Kay is a great heroine – interesting, brave, witty, and full of self-knowledge, and the story is genuinely mysterious. And although this is maybe a niche claim, museums are absolutely excellent settings for scarey goings on, and any scene in a museum at night will give me the shivers. And at the same time, there is a room full of mannequins in dresses, each with a corset over it, because corsets were how Mr Proutman made his money. I would never be less than delighted by a mystery that contained a Corset Room.

And the book also has excellent clothes descriptions, Mrs Proutman’s outfits a particular joy, accessorized with jewellery made of tiny Mexican sombreros - no worries about cultural appropriation back in the day, but still very much available now – these from Poshmark.

$122? really?

Kay: ‘No woman could be completely formidable who had that rather endearing kind of bad taste, I thought, and it was the kindest thought I ever had about Zaydee.’

Kay turns up in a ‘silver fox jacket and the violet homespun…So my hat was as pert, the silvery fur and violet wool as soft and smart as I hoped they were.

– homespun turns up a few times, Zaydee looks ‘handsome in purple homespun and red fox’, so I looked it up:

1 Of domestic manufacture. 2 Plain and homely in character. 3 Fabric woven at home. 4 A loose, rough fabric having the appearance of tweed. I think homespun is all these different things in different places in the book….

Zaydee also wears this corset: “I hear Zaydee wears quite a contraption now. Pink silk and velvet where it shows, but plenty of bones where it hurts.” (Picture is a corset dress, but how could I resist the photo?)

Wallis has a great writing style too:

The street was called Broadway with perfect propriety. It was the widest thoroughfare I have ever seen and the thoroughest. It seemed to go on forever across the world; probably it bisected the whole of the United States.

There is even a mention of one of my favourite books Willa Cather’s The Lost Lady. As well as ‘That year, winter came down early on the prairies. It’s a sentence in every novel of the sturdy pioneers, and it ran through my chilly mind…’ And ‘I had done my best with her furnace, the quality of my performance being just what those words usually imply.’

There are shivarees – helpfully defined as a charivari in one of my dictionaries. ‘A burlesque serenade of newly-weds’ apparently.

Great characters, great plot, intriguing crime, spooky setting, wonderful clothes – this book has everything.

And so I would like to propose this book as the best crime story reprinted during 2020, and kudos to the always wonderful Stark House Press.

A few more items to tidy up:

One question about American life that I have never had satisfactorily answered: Why is ‘commencement’ something that happens at the end of your college career, rather than the beginning? I also always had my doubts about the US dish of “chicken-fried steak,” here excellently described as ‘an unlikely combination of bread crumbs, fat, and old leather belts.’ I also had to work out that ‘jig’ was short for gigolo.

Hat paint plays a small part in the story, not challenging my contention that this substance really is only ever used in murder stories, no-one ever dyed hats in real life... see some major investigation on the subject in this blogpost here.

John at Pretty Sinister Books reviewed this book some time ago.

And Curt at Passing Tramp writes very interestingly about Wallis and her life here - he also wrote the introduction to this re-publication.

It was a Wallis twofer, so I read the second book: 

Blood From a Stone by Ruth Sawtell Wallis

published 1945 

It’s very unusual: young American woman travels to rural France to pursue archaeology, gets involved in all kinds of things. It’s set in the runup to WW2 so the political issues are important. I very much enjoyed reading it, and the descriptions of local life, and the food, and an excellent party scene. There was a weird way in which it was reminiscent of Gerald Durrell’s My Family and Other Animals – both the book and the recent TV series – but with murders thrown in, and none the worse for that. A good easy read, though nothing like as compelling as Too Many Bones, and I did often get lost in the geography of the various bone-filled caves (rather like the heroine). It reads like a first book, with the other so much more assured – I wondered if she’d written it earlier and tucked it away.

Top picture: A look of Kay in her dubious lodgings, though actually I think Olivia de Havilland, who died recently.

Dress with yellow accessories definitely looks like something Mrs Proutman would wear.

The silver fox fur is from some years earlier, but then it is meant to be a gift, presumably pre-worn so that’s OK. The ensemble does not look at all homespun, but it is clear that Kay is stylish and striking, so I decided to use this one, from Kristin.

Yellow dress and hat, also Kristin.

Pictures from the Smithsonian Institute of real archaeologists going about their business: Anne Stine Moe Ingstad, who was Norwegian, and Bertha Parker Pallan [Cody], who was Native American.


  1. So pleased you enjoyed this one. You were definitely spoilt for choice with this one when it came to the clothes. I agree about museums being great settings for scary stories. Waxwork museums probably top the list which Carr and White used.
    Given the more complicated romance and relationship aspects, as well as the fantastic setting and action, I think it would be a great book to adapt for TV. Plenty to work with and probably quite appealing to modern TV watchers. Won't happen of course as Christie didn't write it. I do wonder if I should start a campaign to ban all new Christie adaptations for 5 years, just we can all watch something else for a change... *Kate dismounts from her hobby horse*

    1. Yes, it was the perfect book for me, and am very grateful for the tipoff. And YES what a great TV adaptation it would make, with all those wonderful women's parts, and the museum, and the clothes...
      With my Book Blog Bingo I had you down for 'female nitwit criticism', but the 'love Christie, hate the eternal adaptations' would do for you too! (And for all of us, in fairness)

  2. Kate is undoubtedly the Queen of GA Crime, Moira! And I really like some attention being given to reprints. Kudos to the publishers who are finding these gems and making them available to modern readers. I love it! And your choice is a fine one. It's a good reminder that there's a real treasure trove of GA crime fiction out there to explore...

    1. It is so nice to see attention being paid to these lost books. This is one of the best 'lost masterpieces' I have read - I wonder what other gems are out there? This meme is a good way to find them.

  3. "Why is ‘commencement’ something that happens at the end of your college career, rather than the beginning? "
    Perhaps the end of college is when reality commences? As Tom Lehrer put it: "You'll very soon be sliding down the razor-blade of life."

    1. Pretty much -- think of it as "launch." We do also say "graduation," of course. "Termination" or "conclusion" or "it's over, 'bye" all sound a little harsh.

    2. Looks like de Havilland to me.
      Interesting looking title. My library does not have it 😪

    3. Thanks Roger, nbmandel and KenB

      Someone (Meryl Streep?) said in a commencement address words to the effect of; 'You probably think real life will be like more college. Too bad - it's like more High School', which made me laugh a lot.

      I think we just have graduatiuon in the UK.

      Ken, I really like that picture, I think it is an unusual one of her, but lovely. And I hope the book turns up in your library!

  4. Stark House Press are great, aren't they? They've been doing an excellent job bringing some of these vintage writers back into print. One for my list, I think...

    1. I think you will like it Jacqui, really great women characters, fascinating setting, career details - what more do we ask for in a great book 😉?

  5. Ah, looks like I need to hunt down Too Many Bones.

    By the way, a proper chicken-fried steak -- fried chicken but with beef -- is scrumptious. Assuming the steak is tender, that is. The thinly cut steak is coated in egg, dipped in lightly seasoned flour, and fried in very hot fat. It is served as soon out of the pan as it can be, usually with a milk-based gravy, and vegetable sides. It should be fairly tender, and the crust delightfully crunchy. It's yummy and not at all healthy; country-style (rural-style, down-home cooking) restaurants serve it here in the U.S. South, and portions of the midsection. A hefty schnitzel, if you will, and without the lemon to cut the richness.

    Many thanks again for a delightful series of posts,

    In the Kentucky Bluegrass,
    other side of the pond

    1. Thanks Natalie, lovely to see you here, and you have most definitely made it sound delicious! If I ever get back to the USA I will find a good version...
      and thanks for the kind words.

  6. I also downloaded it on Kate's recommendation and this makes me want to get to it soon. And to write a story set in a museum . . .

    1. Oh YES Chrissie please do! You are a natural for that. And I am sure you will love this book.

    2. I've read it now and yes, was really gripped. It's good in all sorts of ways, though I did guess a central plot point pretty soon.

    3. I think I know which bit you mean, but I didn't find it effected my enjoyment of the book, as it is was very tense waiting for that particular event to strike.

    4. I love this spoiler-free discussion!

  7. Not something I'm qualified to comment on!

  8. The reprint has a great skull cover so I will be getting it for sure sometime.


Post a Comment