Best Shipboard Books–And a Late Addition


Lady Killer extra 2


What with Nicholas Blake’s Widow’s Cruise on the blog on Sunday – and with reading an excellent 40s book from Elizabeth Sanxay Holding (see below) I got to thinking about great books set on boats. And then we all love a list… so here’s my best shipboard blog entries:

1) Singing in the Shrouds by Ngaio Marsh. One of her best: a splendid collection of diverse and sharply-defined characters, all travelling from England to Cape Town – the grumpy spinster, the TV show host, the pedantic schoolmaster, the Anglo-Catholic priest, the young doctor. Is one of them the serial killer called the flower murderer? And Mrs Dillington-Blick is a fabulous character.

2) Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie One of my favourites of hers. Contains an excellent version of the ur-scene, where one character introduces all the other characters by speculating on their clothes and possible foibles, comparing the people in the dining room to the passenger list.

3) The Golden Rendezvous by Alistair MacLean A splendid thriller, with a takeover of the boat by villains, and one of MacLean’s best and most endearing heroes.

Lady Killer extra 1

4) The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold – Evelyn Waugh’s alter ego noisily going mad on a Mediterranean cruise. A kind reader has pointed out that while Pinfold passes through the Mediterranean, he is not on a Mediterranean cruise: he is on a ship travelling to Ceylon with cargo and passengers. 

5) And Brideshead Revisited, also by Waugh, contains a memorable love affair on a transatlantic crossing...

6) ….one that, in a weird way, I used to illustrate Paul Gallico’s Mrs Harris goes to New York, although the two books could hardly be more different. You’d have to read the entry to find out.

7) Murder in the Atlantic by John Dickson Carr – great tense atmosphere of civilians crossing the from new York to England in the early days of WW2.

8) The Man in the Brown Suit by Agatha Christie. Stars one of my favourite of Christie’s women: I had been spelling her name as Anne Bedingfield for the past 40 years, and someone pointed out to me the last time I mentioned her (this post) that I’d been getting it wrong for 40 years, and it is actually Beddingfeld. Embarrassing.

9) My Friends the Misses Kindness by Jane Duncan. Nearing the end of this inexplicable but compelling series and heroine & narrator Janet is on board a ship travelling from the West Indies back to the UK. Of course she meets all kinds of strange people.

And then  we will put in at number 10 this excellent book:



Lady Killer by Elizabeth Sanxay Holding

published 1942


Lady Killer 1


[Honey has recently married a much older man: they are going on a cruise to the Caribbean together]

She rose and bathed and put on a yellow linen dress and a yellow sweater, she put two little yellow bows in her long hair, and a pair of blue and yellow play shoes on her bare feet. Cruise clothes, she thought. When I used to model them, I always wondered if I’d ever get a chance to wear them.

Lady Killer 2
She went out into the alleyway, and it pleased her to walk in these heelless shoes. She felt so very well, so light, so nimble. She opened the door and went out on to the promenade deck.
She stepped into the world she had dreamed of; this was what she had wanted. The blue sky, the
Lady Killer 3blue and sparkling water, the fresh breeze, plenty of people, lovely clothes…

After lunch she sat on deck with Weaver, and when he wanted to take a nap, she put on one of her new bathing suits and went into the little pool.


commentary: This is a delight: a very atmospheric thriller with an excellent heroine, and terrific clothes. Honey is a smart, realistic and quite tough young woman: she worked as a model and then grabbed her chance to marry a man with money. She occasionally misses her old life ‘that was a nice little apartment I had with Annette’, and she rather admires an older fellow passenger called Alma: a very successful businesswoman who made a fortune from beauty products. But Honey is making the most of life, and of the clothes her new status brings her:
When I get a really good tan, she thought, I’ll start to wear white. Honestly I think a blonde with a good even tan, in a white dress, is stunning. But tonight she wore a black evening dress with long full sleeves; she looked slight, delicate and wistful. With a little blue eye shadow.
And indeed later she puts on ‘a dress of ice-white sharkskin’ – an item I loved imagining, though I was not able to find a picture up to my standards.

But as the cruise proceeds, her relationship with Weaver deteriorates, and she is also very suspicious that something funny is going on with the newly-wed businesswoman in the next cabin. There are trips ashore to rather unnerving island towns, and a new passenger comes aboard – she is slatternly, but undoubtedly sexy: an adventuress. The author builds up a very difficult atmosphere: and it is clear that Honey is right to be suspicious, but no-one will take her worries seriously. She is a brave and real heroine and I liked her a lot. And the plot was satisfyingly complex, with an extraordinary ending – you kind of said ‘Oh no’, but there was also an inevitability to it. Though the final final ending is by no means certain… I can say no more.

Absolutely great stuff, and short, no more than a novella.

In my edition it was matched with another novella by the same author, Miasma, which was also a short sharp shocker about a sinister doctors’ practice in small town. It was also very entertaining and mystifying, but not as unusual as Lady Killer.

Girl on a boat with the suspicious face from the Australian Maritime Museum, taken by Sam Hood: Australian photographer whose pictures I have used endlessly on the blog.

Next picture from same source. The woman on the left looks as though she may have just eaten something poisoned… and on this ship you never know.




























Comments

  1. Some good choices there! Mostly ones I haven't read but then that does mean I have them to look forward to. The only three other choices I can think of, off the top of my head, are Herring on the Nile by L C Tyler, Murder in Pastiche by Mainwaring and Murder on the Leviathan by Akunin. I had been tempted to include Sunken Sailor (1961) by Patricia Moyes, but that's more boats really.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the additions, and boats are fine, bring them on! You've made me remember CS Forester's Death Under Sail, about a small group of people out sailing (guess what happens next). I haven't read that Moyes, but am slowly working my way through...

      Delete
  2. I like your choices for shipboard books, Moira! There's just something about that setting that lends itself to a good story, isn't there? All sorts of disparate people at close quarters... Lady Killer looks great, too. I respect an author who can build up tension, develop characters, and so on, all within the space of a novella. And I especially like that there's a strong female character.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks margot, and yes, Honey is a winner: she's not the perfect innocent young girl (as might be in a Patricia Wentworth), she's much tougher than that and has something of a past. A really, great, unusual character.

      Delete
  3. What a lovely post. I will definitely be looking for Lady Killer. And a couple of others on the list. I could never come up with lists like this because I had entirely forgotten The Man in the Brown Suit.

    I will have to stop by later with my two recently purchased books set on cruise ships, and will see if I can think of more. Probably all unread so I can't recommend them as yet.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you would very much like Lady Killer - it's got a very memorable setting, and a great heroine, and it goes in all kinds of unexpected directions. And the details of the early 1940s are splendid.

      Delete
  4. My latest purchases that are also shipboard mysteries are The Queen and the Corpse by Max Murray and Board Stiff by Robert James (who also wrote Death Wears Pink Shoes which you sent to me). I also have Voyage into Violence by the Lockridges... have had it for years. My husband has Charlie Chan Carries On by Earl Derr Biggers. I have read none of these but just for the setting, I think they will be fun.

    I did enjoy The False Inspector Dew many years ago and I would like to reread it someday. I don't know if Polar Star by Martin Cruz Smith fits, but it is my favorite Arkady Renko book.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really like both Max Murray books that I have read, I must try to find this one: and the Robert James one sounds good too.
      Now I really want to re-read Inspector Dew. I've only read Gorky park of the Renko books - I know you are a big fan, I must read more of them.

      Delete
  5. And, I forgot to say, you found fantastic images for this post.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have an e-copy of Lady Killer that I have got to get around to reading (so many books, so little time).

    Meanwhile, have I already give you this blog link? She's a Frenchwoman and every Monday posts selections from her vintage sewing and knitting magazine collection (although I have not yet spotted a white sharkskin resort outfit there).

    http://benesaddict.fr/category/vintagerie/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You have pointed it out before, but I am always ready to be reminded of it. Amazing images... We will keep waiting for ice-white sharkskin.

      Delete
  7. Not a murder mystery but I loved Laurie Graham's 'At Sea'.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh I love Laurie Graham, but don't know that one so will go and look it up. Thanks. And they absolutely don't have to be crime books!

      Delete
  8. Susanna Tayler19 July 2018 at 14:55

    The Nylon Pirates by Nicholas Monserrat is set on a cruise ship (actually I think it's a transatlantic liner, but it's that late 1950s/early 60s period where liners are being superseded by jets and the company needs to make money). It has a group of shady characters aiming to scam their fellow passengers in various ways (blackmail, cardsharping etc).Some rather "of its time" icky attitudes to sex and race (they stop in South Africa) but there were some bits I enjoyed - mainly when it was more similar to The Cruel Sea, such as a description of a storm, or the captain remembering his time on the North Atlantic convoys. And no surprise that the heroine is saved from her sordid life by the love of the earnest British junior officer...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That sounds unmissable! Not sure if I've read any Montserrat, though I know Cruel Sea was on every family's bookshelf when I was growing up. 'Nylon pirates' is such a weird phrase...

      Delete
  9. Moira: As I read your post I reflected that the cruise books you mentioned were all written and set decades ago. The cruising of that era is much different from the cruising I have done in the past 10 years. Further reflection on current cruise mysteries made me realize I cannot recall contemporary cruise mysteries beyond Tapas on the Ramblas by Anthony Bidulka. There must be cruise mysteries of today but I am not familiar with them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, you'd think there must be - such a great setting. Perhaps you should write one, Bill, as you are an experienced cruiser? You would have to combine it with excellent legal content of course...

      Delete
  10. I'll go with Carl Hiaasen's Skinny Dip and Charles Williams and Dead Calm. Though I did also enjoy a pirate murder mystery recently - Steve Goble's Bloody Black Flag!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nice additions thank you! I think I was tempted by the pirate one, I do have a soft spot for pirates...

      Delete

Post a Comment