Stage Door Enquiries: Light Thickens by Ngaio Marsh

Light Thickens by Ngaio Marsh

published 1982

 

 


 

One of my favourite of Ngaio Marsh’s crime novels is her Death at the Dolphin from 1966, which I described as ‘a hugely enjoyable romp through the putting on of a play at a restored old theatre.’

Tuesday Night Club: Ngaio Marsh's Death at the Dolphin

She returns to the same theatre and some of the same people for Light Thickens. This time it’s a production of Macbeth, famously a very unlucky play, prone to severe troubles. This is not going to be underplayed.

I do like theatrical mysteries -  I even have my own logo for them:


But this one....  Many people really like one aspect of the book, which is that although there are some worrying or slightly suspicious goings-on, no murder happens till a long way in (p134 of 222 in my copy), and that the first part of the book is wholly concerned with the staging of Macbeth. In detail. I was not interested in that, and was also outraged that Marsh assumed I would be. I thought it was tiresome and boring. But – as I say, I have seen other verdicts that it is wholly enjoyable, or even that there should be more about the staging. So long as you are warned.



Luckily for everyone, Inspector Roderick Alleyn (series sleuth) is in the theatre the night that everything goes wrong, and proceeds to investigate.

The production is using authentic weapons, with an expert to oversee them:  ‘Gaston Sears, as you all know, in addition to being an actor is an authority on medieval weapons and is already working for us in that capacity.’ There is a very important and elaborate and carefully planned sword fight. We can all see where this is going, what with the authentic weapons and all.

There is a nice description of Lady Macbeth’s costume:

a skin-tight gown of dull metallic material, slit up one side to allow her to walk. A crimson, heavily furred garment was worn over it, open down the front. She had only one jewel, a great clasp.



Solving the crime did not hold me up very long. There is  endless discussion of the timing, and the fact that most people have alibis for the moment when the murder must have been committed. It seemed obvious how the murderer got round that, and then it could only be one person. Even when clever old Alleyn finally caught up with the timing issue, they still seemed to think there could be further possible scenarios, in a way that made no sense at all.

In an earlier book by this author

False Scent by Ngaio Marsh

I commented on a plot issue that seemed to stand screaming out to the reader (how the poison was administered) – I said the book was ‘weird and discomfiting: I find it hard to credit that any crime reader wouldn’t guess before the crime took place, it was so obvious.’

This was similar – I couldn’t believe they kept discussing other options, which were clearly not feasible.



However to make up for that – I couldn’t make the slightest sense of the motive, which seemed an outrageous cop-out.

There is an important imaginary play in Death at the Dolphin, going to be resurrected in Light Thickens, and it is about Hamnet Shakespeare. So we DID all know about him already, before Maggie O’Farrell’s successful and enjoyable version

Shakespeare, & the Importance of Bookshops

So: Light Thickens NOT a favourite in the series, but I liked to blog for completism – and because I do so love books set in theatres and finding the pictures for them.

The Prop that Goes Wrong is a favourite theme in a stage setting, and I have written about it extensively. This post:

Stage Door Enquiries - theatrical mystery and prop guns from Derek Smith

also has links to previous instances of the gun, the knife, the heavy weight...

In Agatha Christie’s Nemesis we hear Miss Marple’s view on how the witches’ scenes in Macbeth should be staged, and I think it reasonable to infer those would be Christie’s ideas too. (And, NB Ngaio, she only takes a few lines to tell us)

TNC: Christie & the Wrong Kind of Love

Catriona McPherson’s wonderful Dandy Gilver deals with a performance of Macbeth in this book:

Dandy Gilver and a Spot of Toil and Trouble by Catriona McPherson

The Shedunnit podcast has done one of their excellent spoilered podcasts on this book – Caroline and Leandra liked it a lot more than I did,  so go there for an alternate view.


 Mr. Anderson as Macbeth - NYPL Digital Collections 

Painting of witches | Document: Photograph of oil painting b… | Flickr

Macbeth drinking scene | Original Collection: University The… | Flickr

Comments