My reading of Gladys Mitchell had been blocked by my
inability to get hold of Printer’s Error: I had read many of them, darting all
over the place in the list, but was now trying to fill in the gaps. Printer’s
Error seemed impossible – but my Secret Santa solved the
problem.
What
Went Right, What Went Wrong: Printer's Error
And now I am back on track, and today am bringing two books
to the table
My Father Sleeps by Gladys Mitchell
published 1944
This is a very Scottish book. And it also deals with
Campbells and Macdonalds and Glencoe – a recent interest on the blog, and with
families where someone has remarried, which we also dealt with, all n this post:
Apricot sky by Ruby Ferguson + Campbells, Etiquette, Hamlet
Mrs Bradley is up in Scotland with her assistant Laura
Menzies (the last name is important: Scottish you see). She is due to give a
paper to a learned conference and we gather is having some holiday first. And
we have Laura’s brother Ian, newly-wed and sailing in the area. They all come
across a very unusual character, Hector Loudon, who claims that he or his house
are being haunted, because of an old crime and miscarriage of justice.
Everybody takes off in different directions, and meets more
people. The author carefully tells us where everybody is going, in some detail,
but after the hundredth placename I was losing the will to live, even though I
have visited quite a few of them.
There are old creak-y houses – ‘probably old Mrs McShuffie,
the deceased crofter, had been the last person to kindle peat in that
particular tin’.
And then:
At the same instant that the thunder died away, through the
gloomy house there sounded a sibilant voice.
“They hanged me, they hanged me my son…Where rest my bones? I died like a dog, and who will speak the word to save me? Who guards the secret my son? Your father sleeps. You must wake him.’
This is the ghost speaking. Mrs Bradley ‘listens
carefully’.
Someone is able to make a point about identification
because of having read their palm: looking at a dead body they say ‘it isn’t
his hand… I never forget a hand I’ve read’. I feel this
was an excellently unusual point. She also says that the palm shows the man to
be a criminal.
I mentioned this in my earlier post on fortune tellers:
Can you Predict which Books I will Feature? - Fortune Tellers
There was a lot of wandering around and catching up with
each other and walking and getting the train and sailing. And more and ever more place
names. The only book comparable with this is Tolkien’s The Silmarillion,
officially the most boring book ever written – ‘the siege of Angband lasted
four hundred years’, which is approximately how long it took to read it. It has
at least one new proper name on every page, and I think this book does too.
Although published in 1944, there is no mention of the war,
which is in marked contrast with the other book in this entry:
Brazen Tongue by Gladys Mitchell
published 1940
I do always love a Home Front book, and this one had interesting details. It wasn’t as compelling as some of her other books, though it was more straightforward.
There was a splendid bit conversation covering various
different aspects of the changed world of 1940:
“Most of the shops have given
up sending [ie delivering orders]. It says so in the windows.”
“They will send for me,” said
Lady Selina, getting up to go to her First Aid class at which, now, she was an
instructor.
“But, Mother, that’s horribly unpatriotic.
After all, there’s not much sense in saving your own petrol if you’re going to
waste other people’s.”
“The tradesmen,” said Lady
Selina, “do not come under the heading of ‘other people.’ I trust, Adela,” she
added, “that your lunatic, when found, will be returned to her proper sphere. I
don’t want her brought in to lunch.”
There is a long, interesting description of a shift at a
Control Centre, where Wardens and volunteers monitor and write up what is going
on in the local area. Someone is dressed in
a pair of navy-blue slacks surmounted by a blithe canary jumper
Which enables me to use this splendid all-purpose picture.
Lunchtime
brings a few minutes of rest for these women wor… | Flickr
During the boring moments of her shift, our heroine Sally
took out a detective story,
and settled herself to read. The book was not an enthralling one, however, and
she wondered, not for the first time, why the masters of the craft did not
produce their detective stories a good deal more frequently than was their
custom. A lazy lot, she considered them, and probably indecently opulent, so
that they had no need to bestir themselves more than about once in six months
for the benefit of their public.
Gladys Mitchell produced approximately one book a year…




I am writing a short story set on the Home Front and I am absolutely obsessed by it all, so will definitely be trying to getting hold of Brazen Tongue. Love the recognising of the palm through having read it. Now and then GM plays an absolute blinder. Of course not only did she write a novel a year, she worked full-time as a teacher. On the other hand she didn't marry or have children which must have freed up a lot of time, but still ... I suspect she did not do very much revising. Chrissie
ReplyDeleteYes, good point about time management, and definitely not much in the way of editing.
DeleteReading her is not like reading anyone else, and I always enjoy her books, even if sometimes I end them and think I still have no idea what happened
Maybe not in this book, but I remember a big deal made of the pronunciation of Menzies (with an Australian variation too, I think).
ReplyDelete"This book" referring to My Father Sleeps, just be clear!
DeleteWinking at the Brim.
DeleteI didn't remember that (except to know it wasn't in this one) and of course Nick Fuller was able to put us right. I will get to that one eventually. Thanks Nick!
DeleteThe Home Front is such a great setting for a novel, Moira. I'm not surprised you liked that one. So much there to explore. I'm struck, though, but the the palm reader's comment. I'd never thought of being able to identify a hand from having read the palm, but that is staying with me. I could definitely see that as a factor in a story....
ReplyDeleteIt's a really good point isn't it? I bet you could do something good with that...
DeleteI'm surprised I've never come across this plot device before
Don’t mention the war… Lots of wartime authors ignored the conflict, just as other writers in other times made no mention of events going on around them. Think of Jane Austen who never directly referenced war or slavery. Way back during lockdown I discussed this with a friend who writes romantic novels and was undecided whether to set her work in progress against the backdrop of the Covid pandemic. We felt that people know just how awful life can be in situations like this, and consequently they don’t want to read about it - they want escapism!
ReplyDeleteThat was me.
DeleteInteresting that some of her books did feature the war a lot, while others didn't mention it.
DeleteAnd I suppose readers vary as much in what they want to read about in wartime or other difficult eras