LOOKING AT WHAT GOES ON UNDER THE CLOTHES
the book: Brooklyn by Colm Toibin
published 2009
One morning, when she had been there for three weeks and was
on her fourth, Eilis knew that something strange had happened as soon as she
reached the other side of Fulton Street and could see the windows of
Bartocci’s. They were covered in huge banners saying famous nylon sale. She did
not know that they had planned to have a sale, presuming that they would not do
so until January. In the locker room she met Miss Fortini, to whom she
expressed surprise. ‘Mr Bartocci always keeps it a secret. He supervises all
the work himself overnight. The whole floor is nylon, everything nylon, and
most at half price. You can buy four items yourself. And this is a special bag
to keep the money in because you can only accept exact change. We’ve put even
prices on everything. So no dockets today. And there will be tight security. It
will be the biggest scramble you’ve ever seen in your life because even the
nylon stockings are half price. And there’s no lunch break, instead there will
be free sandwiches and soda down here, but don’t come more than twice. I’ll be
watching. We need everyone working.’
Within half an hour of opening there were
queues outside. Most women wanted stockings; they took three or four pairs
before moving to the back of the store, where there were nylon sweater sets in
every possible colour and in most sizes, everything at least half off the
regular price. The job of the sales assistant was to follow the crowd with
Bartocci carrier bags in one hand and the cash bag in the other. All the
customers seemed to know that there would be no change given.
commentary: A second look at this book - it's not a January sale above, but there's a fellow-feeling.
The passage is so specific, and so detailed, that I
feel it must have been based on actual events in Brooklyn, but I have not been
able to identify any similar sale. Bartocci’s was the department store invented
for the book.
Equally gripping is the description of the store’s deciding
to start to ‘welcome coloured women’ through its doors: they will offer new
shades of nylons – Red Fox, and Sepia, and Coffee. Eilis, the heroine, is one
of the young women assistants chosen to help the new customers – something she
does without any 21st century priding herself on her tolerance.
Toibin IS a very good writer, and I think
many others would have put some out-of-time thoughts into Eilis’s head.
In the previous entry I said I was less enthusiastic than
others about the book – but I do admire the writing. I liked the landlady, Mrs
Kehoe, when bad news has arrived:
Mrs Kehoe was full of kindness and
sympathy, but there was also, Eilis thought, a sense that the news and the
visitors had caused excitement, distracted her pleasantly from the tedium of
the day.
--the watchful Eilis notices these things. And then later:
And she saw all three of them –
Tony, Jim, her mother – as figures whom she could only damage, as innocent
people surrounded by light and clarity, and circling around them was herself,
dark, uncertain. She would have done anything then, as Nancy and George walked
down the aisle together, to join the side of sweetness, certainty and
innocence, knowing she could begin her life without feeling that she had done
something foolish and hurtful.
The whole book comes through Eilis’s point of view, and it
certainly is an achievement.
The Chief Guest Blogger, Colm Redmond, wrote
about Elizabeth Smart with this strangely appropriate line from By Grand
Central Station I Sat Down and Wept:
I see her often, battling for bargain stockings in Macy’s
basement…
Sheers, O you mad frivolous sisters, sheers.
Sheers, O you mad frivolous sisters, sheers.
And there are many other entries about stockings and nylons on the blog - it’s a Clothes in Books special subject, what with our piece for the Guardian as well – click on the labels below for posts and pictures.
The 2nd picture is a department
store in California, but right era. The long legs are a 1950s advert for
seamless stockings.
It does sound so realistic - that bit about not coming more than twice for the sandwiches, for instance. Your posts from this book are making me more and more curious about it -- not an author I've read as yet.
ReplyDeleteIt is a very strange book, and it does not get my whole-hearted recommendation, but its description of everyday life is fascinating, and it contains just the kind of details that you and I like...
DeleteI do like that passage about the sale, Moira. It conveys the sense of urgency, and the sense that this was as much a social event as anything else. And that's what department store sales used to be like, I think. And it's fascinating the way stockings used to be such an important part of dress.
ReplyDeleteYes, he certainly gets that right, and reading contemporary fiction shows, as you say, the importance of stockings, and the comparative expense compared with today.
DeleteOh, stockings. Can't help but ask since I just saw this, in which Hercule Poirot book does an episode with stockings provide a clue to the Belgian detective about which suspect is dishonest?
ReplyDeleteCards on The Table! Good catch Kathy. I am always fascinated by the way women's clothes reflect the 20th century, and have written about that for the Guardian, using eg stocking or trousers as the framework. I generally quote from many books, but I always think a) crime fiction provides the best examples and b) Christie alone could give you the full sociological history of 20th cent England.
DeleteThanks, but an author I'll pass on (did I say that last time? probably)
ReplyDeleteOnly what I'd expect....
DeleteMight be interesting but I can only read so many non-mysteries in a year. And I am way behind on the ones I already have. I am just a mystery junkie.
ReplyDeleteStick with your genre if that what suits you Tracy! Don't forget, I read some of these books so you don't have to...
Delete