In A Summer Season by Elizabeth Taylor
published 1961
Blogfriend Christine recommended In A Summer Season, having
remembered not one but TWO choice moments from a jumble sale – a cardigan and a
pogo stick.
- jumble sales much discussed on the blog recently:
The Intricate World of Literary Jumble Sales
Graham Greene: The Man for a White Elephant Stall
The setting of this one is a small Home Counties village – near Windsor,
everyone keeps looking at the Castle – and the daughter of the house, 16 yo
Louisa, has a crush on the curate, Fr Blizzard, so gets roped in to the jumble
sale, despite her mother, Kate, never going to church. Louisa is not going to
get far with him, as he is on the way over to Rome, but their relationship is
very enjoyable.
We are all used to the mild trope of someone putting down
eg a jacket (their own, smart) at a sale or charity shop, and its being swept
up and sold. Here there is a nuanced variation:
She had only removed her
cardigan for a moment… turning to look for it a minute or two later, had found
it laid out on a stall, marked fourpence.
Highly insulting.
Then this happens when the curate tries to join in:
‘And what is this magnificent
object?’ he asked, with an attempt at joviality.
‘It is the pogo-stick my
brother and I played with when we were children,’ said Miss Buckley, who felt
that she had sacrificed it. Her
brother’s having been killed in the war, as everybody knew, made an added
embarrassment for Father Blizzard.
Which sent me off to find the history of pogo-sticks, as I
wrongly thought they arrived in, say, the 1950s; they didn't.
These are the kind of moments Taylor excels iin – small and
specific, but recognizable to us. This is not my favourite of her books, but it
is very intriguing.
Kate, widowed after a happy marriage, has married Dermot, a
younger man who is flighty and unreliable and who doesn’t seem able to work.
Luckily Kate is wealthy. It is made startlingly clear that they have an immense
sexual attraction to each other, which they do not resist. It is splendid to
see them enjoying themselves so much.
Kate has two children, Tom, 22 and trying to go into the
family business, and the schoolgirl Louisa.
Dermot’s mother is a tremendous ghoulish figure in London,
always trying to interfere in the family, and full of terrible ideas. Her
dialogue is wonderful. I loved that she says ‘Hello stranger’ when Dermot or
Kate visit or phone, and how dispiriting this is for them.
Kate used to be part of a pair of couples who were best
friends, saw each other all the time. Now her husband Alan is dead, and so is
her great friend Dorothea. The other member of the quartet, the widowed
Charles, is about to return to his house in the village, along with his
daughter Araminta, who has been away at school.
All will be disrupted, but in a gentle, Taylor-esque way –
at least to begin with. Araminta is minx-y and beautiful, so Tom falls in love
with her. Charles is meeting Dermot for the first time, and can’t help
contrasting him with the dead Alan, who was Charles’ friend from schooldays.
Also living in the lovely Home Counties house is an aged
Aunt Ethel who trundles round observing, then writes long indiscreet letters to
her old friend Gertrude: ‘we were in Holloway prison together years and years
ago’ – ie they were Suffragettes back in the day. These two unmarried women
freely discuss Kate’s sexlife – and there is plenty to talk about – in a modern
and psychological way. Then Ethel says ‘burn this’ in her letter, ‘as if any of
the people mentioned it might travel down to [Cornwall] to go through Gertrude’s
desk out of curiosity’.
There is a cook, Mrs Meacock, who is allowed status as a
full character, though I felt Taylor was paying lip service to this.
Mrs M cooks for a splendidly awful dinner-party with
expected and unexpected guests, and a dubious main course. And some terrible
conversations.
Tom has bought himself a TV, and I loved the description of
him and Dermot sneaking off to watch it. ‘Too good an evening to waste out of
doors’ Dermot would say as they drew the curtains against the sunlight. Ethel
pops in, and lingers, pretending she isn’t watching.
Tom and Dermot sat rigid and
in silence. From time to time, their hands groped on the floor for their
glasses of light ale, the cigarettes burnt to their fingers.
‘You’ve got to sleep in
here, Tom’ Kate said crossly, flapping at the smoke-haze..
I’ve been talking lately about authors who give all their
characters a fair chance, they don’t create horrible people in order to then
criticise them. Taylor is one of these good ones: although it is clear that Kate
is the heroine, everyone in the book gets a fair deal. And although you
wouldn’t be in much doubt that Taylor is one of those who disapprove of
television, she has Kate sternly telling Tom to read a book instead, ‘not
realising that she very seldom read herself these days and was just off for an
evening in the pub with Dermot.’
Araminta wears unusual and dicey clothes – a dress made
from a length of black silk draped round herself, and a cheongsam which splits
more every time she moves in it. The clothes are attention-grabbing, but very
temporary, slipping and falling. Nearly all men who meet her are entirely charmed by her.
It has to be said that the book has a most unexpected
ending, one that reviewers called brutal. It is also abrupt. I wanted to know
more about the future of the characters – sign of a very good book.




Yes, a very good novel - and a startling end. Not the kind of thing that would happen in a Barbara Pym novel, I feel. There is more of a dangerous edge to Elizabeth Taylor, I feel. And Kate's unfortunate hair do is a brilliant touch. Chrissie
ReplyDeleteHow true about Pym! So many wonderful details, it made me laugh and wince with recognition throughout.
DeleteI love this book, and Aunt Ethel is a brilliant creation. There's so much in it, like the way Dermot assumes that Mrs Gereth is a real person, such an awkward moment. Brutal is a good word for the ending.
ReplyDeleteYes, and she does it so well: no-one is trying to get at Dermot or make him feel bad, and it is perfectly reasonable not to know a character from the Spoils of Poynton. But she makes you feel the awkwardness so well....
DeleteThese characters sound so well-construction, Moira! And it is nice when, as you say, all the characters get a fair shake. The writing style has that sly wit in it that always draws me in, too. I can see what appealed to you here.
ReplyDeleteOnce I get into the rhythm of Taylor's writing, I could read her all day
DeleteI've never read Elizabeth Taylor, and I've always vaguely assumed she was a more serious writer. But when you started sharing snippets of dialogue and observations, I began to get a Barbara Pym vibe. I was just anticipating ordinging it from the library; then I came to the reference to the brutal ending.
ReplyDeleteMaybe not, then.
Still, jumble sales and Fr. Blizzard...
I honestly think you would enjoy it! She is generally seen as a serious writer, but also entertaining. And the ending - well. Open to discussion.
DeleteMe again. Okay, it's on order fromthe library, and I am #2 in line.
DeletePlease report back!
DeleteI was reading some other reviews which suggested that Dermot was based on the man murdered by Ruth Ellis, and that Taylor knew the murdered man and his family and may have been somewhat attracted to him. Just speculation, but who knows?
ReplyDeleteWhoa, that is really interesting, I've never heard that. Fascinating if true....
DeleteThere's a biography of Taylor by Nicola Beauman who founded Persephone Books (it's called The Other Elizabeth Taylor, wouldn't you know). I just read a Guardian review of it from way back and it sounds as if, like Pym, Taylor may have not had a prim and proper past!
DeleteThat doesn't surprise me... though I have been reading and liking her for a long time without ever having any great curiosity about her personal life, don't know why.
DeleteThank you for the recommendation! I enjoyed this book very much. I wonder if Dermot had dyslexia, and perhaps dyscalculia as well, and that was why he couldn't manage to do anything much. I do think if you marry an alcoholic for sex you will at some point be very disappointed, so perhaps the ending is the easiest way out for both Dermot and Kate, though not for . . . well, no spoilers. I too loved Aunt Ethel, in fact I feel a certain kinship!
ReplyDeleteDeffinitely a possibility about Dermot, and would never have been diagnozed back then. I love this sentence in your comment: 'if you marry an alcoholic for sex you will at some point be very disappointed'. A usedful rule for life!
DeleteThe sex is so convincing! I always feel that it is a slight failing in Barbara Pym's A Glass of Blessings that the relationship between Wilmet and Rodney seems rather opaque. Good as she was, I think married life and sex and children were not something she could write about well, whereas Elizabeth Taylor excels at that.
DeleteYes, you sum that up very well
DeleteYou say this isn't your favourite, Moira, so which is? Would very much like to know. Chrissie
ReplyDeleteA Game of Hide and Seek, which is a wonderful book. But there are some I haven't read, or read a long time ago (when I honestly think I was too young to appreciate her) so as I slowly read my way through I may find one even better! What's yours?
DeleteI like A Wreath of Roses, though it is slightly marred for me by an element of melodrama. Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont is brilliant. Ages since I have read A Game of Hide and Seek. Must reread it.
DeleteNow I'm wanting to read them all! I have Mrs Palfrey in my intermediate pile of books to read. Maybe I should move it up...
DeleteThe top photo seems to show tattoos on the woman's left arm - not something you'd ex[ect in an Elizabeth Taylor character.
ReplyDeleteIs Fr Blizzard "on the way over to Rome", as in turning papist, or becoming Anglo-Catholic? The latter does not preclude marriage.
- Roger
I thought about this after reading your comment: I think Araminta in the book if she was a modern young woman definitely would have tattoos, though perhaps less likely in 1961.
DeleteNo, Fr Blizzard is definitely becoming an RC - and his vicar is not pleased....
I'm not sure if someone has already mentioned the wonderful Shirley Hughes' book, 'Dogger', where a beloved toy is lost and then caught up in a jumble sale where it is sold before his owner can retrieve him. It's such a brilliantly structured children's picture book.
ReplyDeleteI haven't read the book you discuss in the blog but your description of it and quotes make me want to! The Elizabeth Taylor book that has stuck most in my memory is Angel - the main character is unforgettable.
I actually have an illustrated letter from Shirley Hughes where she explains to six year old me that Dogger was a real toy. She must have written it on one of her sketches for her Jessie and Chips books.
DeleteAnon: of course - great story from Shirley Hughes. When we lived in the US, those books used to make me homesick, because our English house was just like Alfie's - including being quite messy, which was one of the things I loved about Hughes. Real people, real homes.
DeleteI was thinking I should read Angel again, and you're confirming me in that.
Daniel - how amazing, lucky you! something to treasure. She did always sound as though she was a lovely person.
Dogger comment was from me. I forgot to sign in.
DeleteDaniel - how incredible. What a treasure.
Moira - I thought I saw somewhere that Dogger was going to be adapted for film/tv but now I can't find reference to it. Totally agree the homes and people are comfortingly real.
Thanks Bernadette - I know, sorry, signing in is a pain.
DeleteDogger would make a great film...
Lauren Bravo wrote a lovely piece about the clothes the mums wear in Shirley Hughes's books. https://open.substack.com/pub/laurenbravo/p/the-timeless-style-of-mums-in-shirley?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=f94
DeleteMy favourite character was Mrs McNally's Maureen and I had a red and black striped jumper just like hers when I was about six.
Oh you are so right Susanna - I absolutely loved that piece, speaks to Mums of all generations.
DeleteDaniel, what a treasure that letter sounds! Do take care of it. Yes, I love all the clothes and details in Shirley Hughes.
ReplyDeleteYes, I want to read some of the Hughes books now! The article Susanna mentions above is well worth reading too
DeleteLovely review - and the ending of A Summer Season is such a shock, even on re-reading. I’ve loved all the posts on jumble sales, and the recommendations from other readers. Some of the references I knew, and some were new, and other people seemed to have said what I wanted to say so much better than I could! I’m sure that somewhere in my collection of Persephone old green-spined Virago books there are other mentions of jumble sales, so I will let you know if I find them!
ReplyDeleteThat was me.
DeleteThank you, and you and all the regulars contribute all the time! I still have some jumble sales to come, at least one more post (even though we are all tied up in smuggling right now)
Delete