Count Belisarius by Robert Graves
published 1938
So I did a post
on a book called You with the Roses by James Wellard,
about the life of the byzantine empress Theodora. In the comments, stalwart blogfriend Roger Allen
mentioned that Theodora’s sister Antonina had married a legendary general,
Belisarius, and that Robert Graves had written a historical novel about him –
and another blogfriend, Lucy Fisher, mentioned this book too. She remembered Antonina, a 14 yo entertainer, walking on her hands at a party.
That original post was partly about my childhood love of
libraries and we discussed the fact that stock was a lot more fixed in those
days, much less turnover. And there were books I saw all the time, without
picking them up – and one of them was Count Belisarius. (I shut my eyes and
visualized the spine, and then found a picture of that online…) I worked out
that it was very familiar because one of my key authors back then was Graham
Greene, and I would have been looking for his books all the time, and taking in
Graves in the shelf above as it might be.
It seemed a given that I was going to have to read this
book finally, all these years later….
It’s a long book, 500+ pages, and some of it is very
entertaining and some of it isn’t. A lot of it is about battles and campaigns
and wars, and that does nothing for me. It is like hearing of long ago football
matches, and the tactics used. Just tell me the final score, if you must.
Also chariot races: there is this bit of description, which
I think speaks for itself:
It would be out of place to give a full account of the race; but let me at least describe the seventh and last lap of it. First one Colour had led, then the other, then the first again. By the end of the fifth lap, when the competitors had already covered a full mile, the position was that the first Green chariot was in the inside berth… blah blah blah.
I mean, really? 'First one led, then the other...'
Belisarius did have a very strange and interesting life,
and the book promises well in the opening chapters: born around 500 CE, he is a
young man making his way across the Near East, a real enough person. But the
older he gets, the more blank he becomes. He was a great general and seems like
a man of honour who tried to do the right thing. He was tossed about by the
politics of the day, And there was a popular legend for many centuries that he ended
up begging in the streets. Graves goes along with this, although modern
scholars apparently think the story apocryphal.
According to this book, he encouraged the use of stirrups
by his men – one of those inventions/changes that military historians think was
pivotal and changed the world.
#spoilernotspoiler,
though not for this book: I guess the Palace where the Emperor and Empress live
is the one featured in this
book
(given historical changes) – though to know that is to spoiler the book I’m
linking to. [as I explain in the post, the actual title of the film made of the
book spoilers it too…]
The book is narrated by Eugenius – an invented character.
He is a eunuch who serves Belisarius and Antonina, and whose character
cheerfully comes through. I particularly liked this when they are trying to
escape a siege situation:
On the last night of November we slipped out of the city, 1,500 of us, by the Appian Gate. I, for one, was so happy to be away that I began to sing a Hippodrome song, ‘The Chariots Fly’, forgetting the order of silence; an officer struck me roughly over the shoulder with the flat of his sword, and I ceased singing in the middle of my verse.
Overall I would say that I am glad I read this, but I won’t
be reading it again. If you are excited by descriptions of military campaigns
(and he is supposed to have been one of the greatest generals of all time) then
you might enjoy it. The rest of you: I read it so you don’t have to.
Count Belisarius in the mosaics at Ravenna, Wikimedia
Commons,
Bust of Belisarius by Jean-Baptiste Stouf Wikimedia
Commons
Jacques-Louis David, Belisarius begging for alms. Also Wikimedia
Commons
Thanks, Moira, for the cherry-picking. I do like historical novels, and Belisarius was an interesting person in real life. But it sounds as though the things that interest me about history are not the things that Graves focuses on in the book. And I'm not sure I want to invest 500 pages in a focus that doesn't appeal to me...
ReplyDeleteQuite right Margot! I'm sure it suits some people, but I think there are easier ways to learn as much history as you want....
DeleteI read this years ago, back in the days when I would discover an author and binge read everything they had written. I remember being bored by all the military stuff, but the rest is a total blank!
ReplyDeleteThere's a good story lost in there, IMO. The good bits were great, and I have enjoyed other books by him.
DeleteI am on page 239 of my re-read and feel bogged down by the military campaign minutiae. At the moment we are beseiging Rome(I think - so many seiges, so many campaigns) and I am beginning not to care. It started well , lots of discussion of clothes and status, the importance of silk , male and female vanity but...You with the roses, what are you selling is better in every way. I suppose Belisarius might end up as my subject on Madtermind. Maybe not.
ReplyDeleteEX-actly how I felt. He misled us into thinking it was going to be fun and personality-based!
DeleteYes, the other book was better, and I don't feel the need to read any more about Belisarius. Or military campaigns.
Even before I got to that part of your post, I was thinking that you'd read it so that I don't have to! Chrissie
ReplyDeleteAt least I am providing a useful service...
DeleteSeconding the appreciation of your willingness to take one for the team!
ReplyDeleteSovay
I am taking my bow with both of you!
Delete