Poirot Investigates by Agatha Christie
published 1924
This is part of my catchup programme – filling in the gaps
in my list of Agatha Christie books featured on the blog.
I have entries on a lot of short stories (and am by no means
going to try to do each individually – at least one story from each collection
is my aim) and was surprised to find that I hadn’t done any from this early
book. I have covered many more Marple stories than Poirot ones in fact.
Agatha Christie herself said she churned out the short
stories in those early years. She equated them with house improvements: if she
wanted a new conservatory, she had to write some stories. Later she was less
keen – wanting to keep her good ideas for her novels. But she was very good at
those quick pieces where I visualize her as having a good idea, turning it over
idly in her head, and then deciding it would make a story, rather than a side
clue in a novel. Although, that said, elements from a few of the short stories
are very recognizable as turning up in some form in later novels – and that’s
apart from the classic tropes which appear often in Christie’s works.
The collections are not canonical, apart from The
Labours of Hercules which has a set of 12 themed stories, and often
contents can vary between the UK and the US. I will go with whichever edition
of the books I own. The first story here, The Western Star, actually refers to two
other stories – The Adventure of the King of Clubs and The Affair of the
Victory Ball – which at this stage had not been collected in a book – but turn
up in Poirot’s
Early Cases, collected very late on in her life (1974), and on which I
posted last week. And someone is a friend of a character from The
Mysterious Affair at Styles. Christie can’t really have thought we’d all
still be poring over her stories and making these connections almost 100 years
later, yet here we are…
The Adventure of the
Western Star
‘Here is a young lady, richly dressed – fashionable hat, magnificent furs… Unknown to her, she is being shadowed by three men and a middle-aged woman… what drama is this being played?’
‘That is Miss Mary Marvell, the film star. She is being followed by a bevy of admirers who have recognized her. And, en passant, my dear Hastings, she is quite aware of the fact!’
… and of course she is on her way to see Poirot, to consult
over a magnificent jewel.
Lady Yardley appeared framed in the doorway, a radiant figure in a long white shimmering dress…
the story features jewel theft, shocking orientalism, and
love rivals.
The top picture shows Estelle Bernadotte,
Countess of Wisborg.
In the Mystery of Hunter’s
Lodge there is a ‘very handsome young woman wearing a flame-coloured
jumper… on her dark head was a little hat of flame-coloured leather.’ There are
a number of classic Christie tropes here, including the importance of clothes,
dimly-lit passageways, suspicious alibis – and apparently a lack of certainty
on how to finish off the story: that is one copout ending.
Hollywood by
Alice Pike Barney
The Adventure of the
Egyptian tomb takes Poirot to Egypt (he rides on a camel!) and prefigures Christie’s
later interest in archaeology – it is obviously following on from the recent real
life discovery of Tutankhamun’s tomb by the Carter/Carnarvon party in 1922.
Egypt-mania and Tut-mania swept the world, from parties to décor to theatres.
The picture is a sketch for an Egyptian-themed stage costume by the great designer of the era, Leon Bakst.
The collection … has a few regular Christie moments –
the crime (theft, kidnapping) that takes place before everyone believes, explaining
the impossible. A reminder to look beyond the myths and superstitions and think
about what actually happened. A lot of cheap flats and service flats – well
known to be a subject of great interest to the author in the 1920s, and always
a property mogul, all her life.
The talk fell on the subject of
house-hunting in London. Houses and flats were Parker’s special hobby. Since
the end of the war he had occupied at least half a dozen different flats and
maisonettes…. His moves were nearly always accomplished at a slight pecuniary
gain, for he had a shrewd business head, but it was sheer love of the sport
that actuated him, and not a desire to make money at it.
This could be Christie herself. Two of the stories here, and
one in Poirot’s
Early Cases, centre on flats in the smart service blocks of London, and
they feature in many other of the novels and stories of the 20s and 30s.
As I said about Poirot’s
Early Cases – a nice collection with varied settings and plenty to enjoy.
This was actually one of the first Christie collections I read, Moira. And as I think about it now, I can easily see how she'd have had an idea for a scene or a clue or something and thought it would be much better as a short story. Not all of these stories are, in my opinion, her finest, but I do like to see the way her mind seems to work in them, if that makes sense.
ReplyDeleteThanks Margot - and yes, she doesn't reach her heights here, but there is always much to enjoy. I like to re-read them every so often...
DeleteThe Adventure of the Western Star has an opening that is very much like a Sherlock Holmes story, but we don't get a series of marvelleous deductions from Poirot.
ReplyDeleteIt is also once again an example of Hasting's brutally honest style of narration. Poirot makes a fool of him, but he writes a story for the world to know of the humiliation he felt.
I enjoyed the Egyptian background. Christie is always good when she writes about archeology, but had she met her second husband yet when she wrote this?
Oh you are so right about Western Star, that clicked as soon as you said it.
DeleteThe Egyptian Tomb definitely predates any personal interest in archaeology, and she was still married to Archie - like you I was intrigued and checked! So I think based on the general Egyptian interests of the time. But she had spent time in Egypt when she was a very young woman (pre-WW1): she had her debutante 'season' there, as it was cheaper than doing it in London. It sounds so unlikely...
"The Adventure of the Egyptian Tomb" is the first Hercule Poirot short story I read (I think). And I got to read it before we watched it as an adaptation on TV, and that was very nice. I loved it. I enjoy the Poirot stories mostly for Hastings' narration, and Hercule Poirot's quirks. It was in an anthology of detective stories that was intended to be for children (not sure what age) as an introduction to the detective genre.
ReplyDeleteThat's so interesting Tracy. I am intending to watch the TV adaptation soon.
DeleteDid you know that Christie didn't like the idea of using her stories for children? - she thought murder was too serious. But obviously it was a good idea in your case!