New Year, New Books: Murderous Millennials

Another new book – Lucy Foley has written historical novels in the past: this is a contemporary thriller, out this week

The Hunting Party by Lucy Foley

published 2019

[a group of 30-somethings in Scotland for New Year: they are going shooting as part of their holiday]

We traipse after Doug to the yard behind the Lodge, where his Land Rover sits parked.

Doug opens the barn for us with a state-of-the-art keypad that looks completely bizarre agains the old wood. I suppose they need it, if there are guns in here. As he yanks the heavy wooden door back I enjoy watching his muscles move beneath the old shirt he wears (just a shirt – in this weather!). He would make, I think, an excellent candidate for Lady Chatterley’s lover, so tall and broad and tousled…

He kits us up in the barn: over-trousers and jackets, even walking boots for Katie, who has failed to bring anything remotely sensible.

Beside the jackets and the trousers hang ten rifles.

commentary: Proper outdoor clothes are important in the book – one of the locals in this rugged Scottish Highland hideaway says that ‘the London guests all turned up wearing city people’s idea of rugged outdoor wear – Dubarry boots and Timberlands’. Shocking news that these are not proper bad-weather footwear.

The Hunting Party has an excellent setup: a group of 9 old friends are getting together for New Year, spending a few days in a luxury Lodge with great meals planned and a hunting trip included. The narrative is split between chapters following the group as they arrive and get going, and then ‘Now’ sections where it is obvious that someone has died, that the group has fallen apart, that there is high drama around. The narrative is split between various characters, some of it is in the first person and some in the third, and (oh why do writers do this?) it is in the present tense.

Lucy Foley keeps up the mystery for a long time – at first we just know someone is missing, then we find out the gender, then late on exactly who it is. (I think we were never in any doubt that someone has been murdered, so I won’t include that as secret-keeping.) Everyone has backstory, and secrets, and history with and without the others -and that includes (of course) the people who work at the luxury Lodge, and the two unexpected guests who have been booked in by mistake.

The houseparty is very well done, and very convincing (though obviously we wouldn’t all be ending it in violence): these people have been friends for a long time, maybe too long, maybe things are unravelling, maybe there are incidents in the past that weren’t actually forgiven. And at the same time the holiday sounds great: there are individual cabins, and then a giant central space with living-room and kitchen (and yes of course leather sofas and open fires) and then there is a sauna, and everywhere has huge windows and lovely views of countryside and loch. So that’s a great setup for a crime plot as people walk around meeting each other, peering in windows, spotting lights that shouldn’t be on. But I also kept thinking what a great trip it would be. The shooting party (deer-stalking) sounds awful. Of course all the guests go, vital to the tension and plot, but I found myself wondering how easy it would be to get out of it, what excuse I would have made to stay behind to lie on the sofa in front of the fire reading a detective story…

So a very entertaining read – some of the mysteries rather guessable, but I very much enjoyed the character interactions, the descriptions of the way friendships change, the dynamics when someone has a baby, the wild child who becomes less forgiveable and less charming as she gets older.

A highly entertaining crime book – one to take away with you when you plan a trip with friends. Or perhaps not…

The pictures are from the excellent House of Bruar website, purveyors of country clothes to the gentry.


  1. I really like the setup and premise for this one, Moira. That 'gathering of old friends' premise can work brilliantly in a story. I like perspective on what counts as 'proper' outdoor wear, too! I think that sort of difference can add to a story. And then there's the atmosphere... I can see why you found it entertaining.

    1. Yes indeed, Margot, a good concept. I think it works because we can all picture ourselves in that kind of situation...

  2. This sounds like a good read. If I can get around the present tense narrative, which I find works ONLY if it's in first person all the way. One first person.

    Like you, I'd be curled up by the fire while the others were out killing things. Which could be suspicious in itself. :^)

    1. And you never meet ANYONE who says 'I love a present tense narrative' do you? Where does it come from?
      The person who stays behind on the sofa could easily be lacing the drinks decanter, slipping some anonymous notes somewhere, searching everyone else's belongings, lifting the diamond bracelet. [Not spoiler, none of these are from the book] Though personally I would be too lazy and intent on my book...

  3. Moira: Hunting is so different in Great Britain. In Saskatchewan either camouflage or bright orange are the colours to wear while hunting. I think my hunting friends would be astonished to silence to see anyone show up to hunt wearing a tie. Clearly the gentleman expects the animals and birds to come to him rather than tracking through bush and field. Now I was glad to see the House of Bruar has stylish and suitable jackets to wear outdoors. I knew there had to be stylish warm jackets for women in Great Britain! And the prices for a good jacket are reasonable.

    1. I've never thought about that before, but of course you are absolutely right: in Seattle, too, the whole question of outfitting would be completely different. I fear the Brits are too concerned with what is stylish and upmarket and (at least in the past) rather formal: less so for sheer practicality. I'm glad you approve of the House of Bruar!

  4. Another one that might tempt me.

    1. I did think there was more to your taste in the past week or two! The pre-Xmas books tend not to be your thing...


Post a Comment