Laura by Vera Caspary
published 1943
Laura had become a Manhattan legend. Scarlet-minded headline artists had named her tragedy THE BACHELOR GIRL MURDER and one example of Sunday edition belles-lettres was tantalizingly titled SEEK ROMEO IN EAST SIDE LOVE-KILLING. By the necromancy of modern journalism, a gracious young woman had been transformed into a dangerous siren who practiced her wiles in that fascinating neighborhood where Park Avenue meets Bohemia. Her generous way of life had become an uninterrupted orgy of drunkenness, lust, and deceit, as titillating to the masses as it was profitable to the publishers…
East Sixty-Second Street had yielded to the spirit of
carnival. Popcorn vendors and pushcart peddlers, sensing the profit in
disaster, offered ice-cream sandwiches, pickles, and nickel franks to buzzards
who battened on excitement. Sunday’s sweethearts had deserted the green
pastures of Central Park to stroll arm-in-arm past her house, gaping at daisies
which had been watered by the hands of a murder victim.
Fathers pushed perambulators and mothers scolded the brats
who tortured the cops who guarded the door of a house in which a bachelor girl
had been slain.
comments: Always good to be reminded that intrusive and tasteless press coverage, and public fascination with crime, was not invented recently.
Next point: WHY do I keep getting the name wrong? When I originally wrote a post
on this book, I called it Vera by Laura Caspery. I was doing it in a hurry, but
still, what was I thinking of? They are not at all the same kind of first name:
I have a filing system in my brain for names, and they are nowhere near each
other. (And I should be able to copy a last name.)
The reason I wrote about it before was that I took part in
a podcast on it with my old mate Sergio Angelini, over at his wonderful Tipping My
Fedora
Tipping
My Fedora: Laura, a classic film and book....
- I
strongly recommend looking through his backlist, as my readers here are sure to
find topics to tempt them (as well, of course, as hanging onto MY every word).
One of the topics Sergio and I discussed was an outfit that
appeared in the film of Laura on her tricksy aunt Ann Tredwell (Susan in the
book). You can see it in the picture.
Sergio – a man with a conoisseur’s eye – asked me ‘why is she wearing a tablecloth tied over her dress?’ Tut. We had a helpful (and highly enjoyable) technical discussion on overdresses and apron dresses. Recently I came across a fashion drawing from the era, by Schiaparelli (that’s a top designer, Sergio) which had a similar look, and that put me in mind to do another post on the book…. And an excuse to find some more pictures
Incidentally, Ann T is played by the wonderful Judith
Anderson, who stands out even amidst the stellar cast of Laura: she has such
charisma, she steals every scene she’s in. (If you are wondering where you know
her from, her most famous role is as Mrs Danvers the housekeeper in Hitchcock’s
Rebecca)
Waldo Lydecker, a key player, mentor and confidante to
Laura, pads around in very fancy dressing-gowns.
The body in the apartment meanwhile is discovered in
A blue silk taffeta robe and a pair of silver slippers
-the top picture suggests a lot more liveliness than that.
Waldo describes Laura:
...she wore a gown of champagne-colored chiffon and
jade-colored slippers. Extraordinarily effective with her eyes and hair.
In a pink bed, wearing a jacket with fur on the
sleeves, lay Mrs. Susan [ie Ann] Treadwell
This is of course actually Vivian Leigh/Scarlett O'Hara in Gone With the Wind.
Mrs Tredwell is annoyed about Laura's generosity:
Remember that model… the girl with the fancy name? Laura
got me to give her my leopard coat. It wasn’t half worn out either. I could
have got another winter out of it and spared my mink.
It’s hard to judge a book that was so famous, that produced
an iconic film (with an iconic piece of music), and that has a famous surprise
in it: and for me one that I first read long ago. But it was a delight to read
again, and you have to admire Caspary’s structure, her cleverness, and her
ability to tell a complex story, in various POVs, over a minimal number of
pages – it is surprisingly short considering everything that’s going on.
And if you want to know more – be sure to check out
Sergio’s and my podcast.
The book is famous for the detective’s obsession with
Laura, an unhealthy love for a corpse, and also for a surprise in the middle,
For both these reasons, the book was mentioned in this
post:
Great endings, and Fredric Brown








Don't tell anyone, Moira, but I made the same name-inversion mistake at first when I did a spotlight on this book. For whatever reason, those names just switched back and forth in my mind. And thanks for discussing the film, too. It's haunting in its way, and I honestly think the visuals in the film bring home the story. I'm usually very much a purist when it comes to film adaptations, but I think this particular film is fantastic. Oh, and you know, overdresses are useful!
ReplyDeleteThanks Margot - that made me laugh and also made me feel better about my mistake!
DeleteAnd yes, great book and great film
My first impression of Anderson's outfit was that she had her apron on backwards, but of course she would never have been wearing an apron in the first place! Anderson's outfit doesn't look as "together" than the Schiaparelli design, I suppose because of the contrast in fabric. I wonder if Anderson was thinking "Does this make my hips look big?"
ReplyDeleteIt is not the most flattering outfit, it must be said, but it was probably very up to the minute.
DeleteSciaparelli definitely superior
She looks as if she’s read or heard about Schiaparelli’s stylish new apron skirts (but not seen one) and decided to improvise, with disastrous results! The high contrast is certainly part of the problem. Mind you, it would be interesting to see the Schiaparelli photographed on a normal, non-model-shaped woman …
DeleteSovay
Mind you the costumes for Laura were done by Bonnie Cashin, a very successful and admirable designer in her own right...
DeleteSpeaking of aprons, I happened upon this McCall pattern from 1949! https://witness2fashion.wordpress.com/tag/peplum-1940s/
DeleteThat is jaw-droppingly hilarious! Love it
DeleteThe Laura and Rebecca stories share a title character who seems to dominate people's minds in spite of not being present physically--like haunting. And of course the song "Laura" has been called haunting. Both stories have famous portraits and equally famous obsessions, although the obsession in Laura was less creepy than in Rebecca. Almost anything would be less creepy than Mrs Danvers!
ReplyDeleteYes - and we continue to love those themes and tropes
DeleteTop picture is Laura the ‘bachelor girl’ as the rubbernecking passers-by are imagining her - I’m pretty sure silk taffeta is much more substantial. I’ve never read the book - must do so.
ReplyDeleteSovay
Why does Laura wear such a drab dress for her "return to life" party? I see it as olive green... Pondering the reverse apron. Was fabric rationing still in force? Looks like a way of pretending you have volume all round. (Lucy)
ReplyDeleteIt does have a look of those Make Do and Mend instructions in the UK: 'take your husband's old shirt, and the maid's overall, and make a bridge-coat' - even in the official ones done for an instruction leaflet they looked awful. But this was the US and a film...
DeleteI think it was an attempt to be stylish & distinctive that didn't come off.
Bonnie Cashin got the wardrobe credit for the film, although I have read (but can't find now) that Gene Tierney's husband at the time, Oleg Cassini, had a lot of infuence.
ReplyDeleteAh interesting. I imagine if you were married to him, you would expect some input
DeleteI just finished reading Bedelia, another book by Caspary. I remember seeing the movie with Margaret Lockwood. She was good but the movie wasn't in the same class as Laura. Caspary worked on the screenplay too.
ReplyDeleteIt never occurred to me to find more books by her! Don't know this book or film
DeleteInternet Archive has several of her books. I'm going to try Murder at the Stork Club next. IA also has her FBI file! She apparently supported some of the blacklisted performers during the McCarthy mess.
DeleteFascinating. And Murder at the Stork Club sounds right up our street
DeleteBedelia had some nice clothes too. IIRC one reviewer said that Lockwood's outfits were more interesting than the plot!
DeleteOh I'm going to have to take a look...
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThe film was set in England in the 1940's, but the book was set in Connecticut before WW1. Having seen the film before reading the book, I was confused at first by the mentions of long skirts and corsets!
DeleteInteresting change - I suppose it was to suit Margaret Lockwood?
DeleteI think it was a British production, by Gainsborough Pictures. The actors were British, anyway.
DeleteIt does sound very Gainsborough
DeleteI read somewhere that Caspary wasn't pleased at the casting of Clifton Webb as Waldo! I can see that he doesn't physically resemble the book's Waldo, but now who could imagine the film without him?
ReplyDeleteYes, he just owns the part now
Delete