We’re into December, so it’s time for the annual Clothes
in Books project of Christmas in Books – seasonal scenes from random
books, for no better reason than I like looking for the pictures, and I and
some readers find them cheery and Xmas-y. This one is not cheery, but it does show an unlikely festive trope which may be familiar...
Many of the entries
- this year and in the past – were suggested by clever readers: so if
you have a favourite please do let me know and I will try to use it
Ember Lane: A Winter’s
Tale by Sheila Kaye-Smith
published 1940
The black jacket is said to be by Schiaparelli, great
blog favourite and much featured this year, and I don’t think
for one moment that Jess, below, or her bridgecoat, looked anything like this. But
it’s very beautiful, and I wanted to give the poor woman something nice
because she has the most awful time in this book… read on
It was not till she had taken out the offending object that
she realized she had unwittingly broken into the secret of what must be his
Christmas present to her. In her hand was one of the gaily decorated boxes with
which the Potcommon Co-operative Stores gave glamour to its Christmas stock.
She hastily put it back…
[her husband brings her tea]
He stooped and kissed her as he gave her the tea; then he
fumbled in his pocket and drew out a little parcel, which he put in her hands.
“Here’s from me with love to you.” For a moment she was too surprised to open
it. “But I thought…” mercifully she did not say it aloud, for her mind, working
quickly, immediately supplied the explanation. Her heart felt as cold as her
hands as she unwrapped the little parcel and displayed a tiny bottle of
eau-de-Cologne.
comments: This is a very notable
scene for two reasons. It was the Year
of the Bridge Coat on the blog, and here’s a rather sad
final one: poor Jess lives in a very cold house. And, it links up with
bedjackets, another CiB obsession.
But also, plotwise this
is a familiar scene to fans of the film Love Actually, where exactly
this happens: a wife (Emma Thompson) finds what she thinks her husband (AlanRickman) has bought her… only to be disappointed. Not only do these women not
get the nice present, but they also realize by how much their husband’s
affections are engaged elsewhere.
Jess goes way too far in her ‘understanding’ of this. She manages to sneak a look at the rogue present:
It was in the spirit of hope
mixed with anxiety that she finally opened the gaudy little box. Perhaps some
kindly saleswoman had counselled his inexperience and persuaded him to a gift
that at least would not add to his offences. She was reassured to find a quite
presentable marcasite clip, the price of which she calculated at from
twelve and sixpence to fifteen shillings. This, though certainly more than he
could afford, was very much less than in his madness he might have spent; nor
had he prepared incrimination for himself with any amorous message. So the
prevailing result of her examination was relief.
Perhaps
like this?
I don’t think Emma T’s character in Love, Actually would have been so self-sacrificing.
The book is a strange but very compelling read. Sheila Kaye-Smith wrote many novels – she was popular in her day, and her rural settings
were one of the inspirations (if that’s the word) of the Stella
Gibbons parody, Cold
Comfort Farm. And this one definitely ventures into CCF
territory, with some particularly un-user-friendly phonetic country talk, and
rather surprising interventions by some ghosts.
The setting is a small village in Sussex, and we are
looking at a handful of families – the couple above are desperately trying to
make money with their chicken farm,
having been on a downward path since Greg left the army at the end of WW1. Note
the simple awfulness of her getting the bridgecoat “for chilly indoor
festivities, of which there had been none.”
We had some brave un-moneyed women wearing bridgecoats
earlier in the year (eg the vicar’s wife in Dorothy L Sayers’ Busman’s Honeymoon - discussed here along with many other bridgecoats), plenty
of people making their clothes last for years – but the grimness of this is OTT.
It is a good book, but Jess’s story really is too much….
There will be another entry featuring other characters: it
is a very suitable wintry book, as in its subtitle.
The provenance of the top picture is hard to parse, but I found it on Pinterest, and am crediting Ludmila Kravchenko.
Picture of tea in bed from the State
Library of Queensland



Now I'm curious who is going to receive that clip!
ReplyDeleteIt seems to me that the clip in the picture is paste - and hasn't the poor thing been in the wars. I found a marcasite double clip brooch here: https://tresors.com.au/collections/marcasite/products/vintage-sterling-silver-marcasite-dress-clip-brooch-1
It seems ludicrously expensive, and could do with a polish. The internet tells me that what is generally called marcasite, is actually pyrite. The small faceted stones are used a a cheap imitation of diamonds.
Clare
Thanks Clare - and watch out! Next week there will be another post on this book, and you will find out the recipient of the gift.
DeleteI thought the clip had the look of a cheap trashy present. It was described as marcasite in the caption.
I took a look at the one you linked to - quite pretty but far too much!
Yes, but Jess considers the clip to be quite presentable, and prices it between 12/6 and 15 shillings. I put those amounts in the currency converter, and 12/6 in 1940 is approx. £24.59 in 2017 (at the moment it doesn't go any further). 15 shillings converts to £29.51, so 2/6 in 1940 is approx. 5 pounds in 2017. It's not an exact science of course, and there's been some more inflation between 2017 and 2025, but it's a fun toy.
Deletehttps://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/currency-converter/
So the clip doesn't cost a fortune, but circumstances are obviously dire, and how much will the tiny bottle of eau de cologne have cost? Sixpence, maybe a shilling?
Clare
Yes, I use the currency converter all the time. There's a particularly good bit of Trollope where uncle and niece are discussing the prices of bonnets, I very much enjoyed that.
DeleteI think your guess about the eau de cologne is right, and the relative prices of the two gifts seem to me to be as expected - Jess is relieved he didn't spend too much (they are very badly off). She thinks it is presentable, but I still think that means it is cheap and trashy.
Obviously the clip is not fine jewellery, but cheap and trashy would be something costing half a crown in Woolworths.
DeleteLooking forward to the denouement next week!
Clare
I can't do a full denoument, for spoilers: his trip to deliver the box sets off the climax of the book.
DeleteBut you will meet Brenda, the woman he is in love with. It is, I think, super-clear that she would not want a gift fom him, and that the clip would not be right for her. She is a well-off, well-dressed widow,
The story is weirdly melodramatic, yet nuanced at the same time. They are not stock characters.
In another strand of the book, a gift from a man to someone else's wife also has dramatic consequences.
Good to spot another example of the unsuccessful ex-serviceman poultry farmer - as discussed in your post on Casual Slaughters. Though that was good fun and this one sounds thoroughly miserable.
ReplyDeleteExactly! Honestly, there is no saving grace in their lives, it was a downside of the book, which in general dealt with some hard times but gave you hope. These two were awful....
DeleteThere's a chicken farmer in a book by stella gibbons can't remember title, just postwar. Lucy
DeleteMmm, just what you'd expect: it will turn up in our reading...
DeleteThat popped into my mind too. I think it might be The Matchmaker.
DeleteI think Christine is correct. One character's life practically revolved around his flock!
DeleteI read The Matchmaker long ago, but couldn't remember anything about it, and now have it on my Kindle for some future read....
DeleteI wouldn’t recommend it. One read is one too many! Started well, but ended up making me want to hurl it across the room. Usually, when books are ideologically unsound/politically incorrect, I think you have to place them in the context of their time. But for some reason this one made me really furious.
DeleteOh actually that is ringing a faint bell, I may have had a similar reaction....
DeleteHurray for the bridge coat! Would the eau de cologne have been 4711?
ReplyDeleteOh brilliant - of course it would. From the old-fashioned chemist's shop in the village...
DeleteAs soon as I read about the bridge coat in that little snippet you shared, I knew it would have appealed to you, Moira. And the story does have a real wintry feel about it. I can't help but feel for Jess - what a way to find out your husband is playing away from home. I'm glad there is some hope in this is; it does sound rather sad...
ReplyDeleteThanks Margot, yes right up my street. It is nicely atmospheric and seasonal, though rather sad...
DeleteSpookily I wss 8nspired to reread Pamela Hansford Johnson 's Night and Silence who is here?(1963) by the Question Mark post and was happy to find Miss Groby, a Slavonic scholar, worried because she had to dress for dinner and had '...only an old black skirt and a bridge-coat with tarnished brocade '...though I do cut off the loose threads, I fear it wouldn't look very smart in a good light'. I find bridge coats are almost everywhere these days.
DeleteOh blimey that is impressive - especially as I had a PHJ bridgecoat in a different book!
DeleteI read it pre-blog and pre-bridgecoat obsession, and was not over-enthusiastic - did you enjoy it, would you recommend a re-read? I'm tempted because of the bridgecoat obv.
PHJ - there are few authors that I have such varied reactions to, love some of hers, not at all keen on others.
Accidental rather than impressive, although if I ever apply to Mastermind
Deletebridge coats in books might be my special subject also true of many of your readers.
Night and silence is the least interesting and amusing of the Dorothy Merlin trliogy and there is little about clothes in it. You could read The Unspeakable Skipton and Cork Street next to the Hatters and enjoy them both without missing this one. Yes, she is an odd writer; some good, some astonishing and some dreary books.
We would make an unbeatable team on bridge-coats.
DeleteChicken farms seem to have been the way to lose your service gratuity after WWI for those who couldn't afford to lose it tea-planting or in Kenya. They crop up in Evelyn Waugh (one of his short stories features a young man who travels around the country threatening to open a chicken farm until he's bought off) and D.H. Lawrence's The Fox has two young women running a chicken farm.
ReplyDelete- Roger
I looked up Sheila Kaye-Smith in Wikipedia, as the name rang a bell. One of her books, Joanna Godden, was the basis for a film with music by Ralph Vaughan Williams, which is where I'd come across it.
DeleteHer own riposte to CCF: "There was nothing written nowadays worth reading. The book on her knee was called Cold Comfort Farm and had been written by a young woman who was said to be very clever and had won an important literary prize. But she couldn't get on with it at all. It was about life on a farm, but the girl obviously knew nothing about country life. To anyone who, like herself, had always lived in the country, the whole thing was too ridiculous and impossible for words."
Yes I looked that up too. I was intrigued by their emphasising that the end of the film had been changed from the book, but not enough to check that out.
DeleteThat quote - it depends on whether she is being funny. Going to CCF for farming details would be rather like that famous review of Lady Chatterley's Lover, which criticizes the way the shoots are run.
Josephine Tey is another one who didn't like rural dramas - a couple of her books feature a horrible man who writes dreary sub-Webb novels.
DeleteI haven't covered any Webb on the blog (though I do like Precious Bane) but there is a Jonathan Coe novel, the Rain Before it Falls, about the making of film of a Webb book
https://clothesinbooks.blogspot.com/2015/10/the-rain-before-it-falls-by-jonathan-coe.html
If S K-S wasn't making a joke about CCF, it's even funnier!
Deletevery difficult to tell without reading the book...
DeleteThis sounds interesting, but it’s expensive for a book I might mot like! I had a similar problem wIth MaryWebb, who was also one of Stella Gibbons’ inspirations (though I think targets might be a better word). Anyway, I HATED Mary Webb. I have found a free online copy of Ember Lane: A Winter”s Tale at the Canadian Project Gutenberg (cheapskate, I know!), but it can’t be downloaded and isn’t on the UK site. Still in copyright I expect. Im only a few pages in but already have high expectations of this!
ReplyDeleteOpenLibrary has Ember Lane, and there's actually a copy to borrow! I won't be reading it, though. This author definitely doesn't sound like my cup of tea!
DeleteYou can find it on The Digital Archive also.
DeleteI wouldn't be rushing to read another by her (she wrote a lot) but I was left with a grudging admiration for the book - it is both ridiculous and uncompromising, and I kept thinking about it after finishing it.
She is very good at creating nuanced characters.
After saying I wouldn't read any books by SK-S, I found Iron and Smoke on Faded page and sort of skimmed through it. The description said it was about the conflict between agriculture and industry in England around WW1, which didn't sound too rustic. It's actually about the life journey of an ironmaker's daughter who marries a cash-poor squire, and there's an interesting friendship between her and the squire's rather remarkable ex-mistress.
DeleteOh well done. I'll bear it in mind. the words 'remarkable ex-mistress' would always tempt me.
DeleteOh dear, Moira, this is too sad! I have to be feeling especially robust to read this kind of thing. The sheer dreary awfulness of it. Ah yes, the chicken farm - I think mushroom farms were other failed enterprises for ex-service men. Chrissie
ReplyDeleteI cannot argue with that - there are 3 or 4 strands in the book, some much more cheerful, but the chicken farm is awful. Each chapter moves to a different character, and I was always disappointed when it turned out to be poor Jess!
DeleteOh dear, not another doomed chicken farm! It does sound pretty grim – it’s good to hear that some of the other characters are in better shape. That clip does look very second-hand, and I agree with Clare that it seems to have been wrongly captioned – I have a old marcasite brooch of my grandmother’s and however much I neglect it, it doesn’t discolour like that.
ReplyDeleteI’ve had a copy of Sheila Kaye-Smith’s “Joanna Gooden” among my TBR books for so long that it’s actually on a shelf, not on the floor. I have made one attempt to read it but was beaten back by the rustic dialect; normally I give a book a second try (because sometimes it’s the right book but at the wrong time) but in this case it might be time for it to go now. All the same I’m tempted by this one if a sensibly-priced copy comes to hand – the ghostly intervention sounds interesting. I've definitively given up on Mary Webb – couldn’t make any headway with either “Precious Bane” or “Gone to Earth”.
Re: S K-S’s riposte to “Cold Comfort Farm” – based on the quotation, I think she gets the joke but the character she’s writing about doesn’t.
Sovay
I just looked up marcasite on Wikipedia - the entry says it "tarnishes to a yellowish or brownish colour". So I may well be wrong!
DeleteSovay
I wouldn't rush to read another one but you never know. Joanna Godden would be tempting because then could watch the film. Perhaps you could read it for me and let me know!
DeleteGone to Earth was also made into a film - it's the one I mention in a comment above: Jonathan Coe wrote about it, and I found some pictures from the shooting set.